
As I said before, “Every buffet in Reno has something that sets it apart from the rest and something that makes it not nearly so great as it could be.”
I believe that. That’s why I wrote it. Duh!
So, we are left with the need to review a buffet. I read in the gazette-journal that Eldorado had recently completely redone their buffet. If you’ve spent a number of years experiencing Reno you’ll know how so very many of us feel about Tivoli Gardens, which was a restaurant-showpiece-extraordinaire and we all lost something the day that the animatronic wall gargoyles stopped working due to water and mold destroying their foam-fabric construction. Still, we miss how their eyes glowed red. Tivoli was awesome. Won’t someone make a new one? Please? (Yes, I know it’s still technically open. But come on…)
Anyway, on to the buffet. This buffet is new and is run or apparently had its menu designed by the guy who runs LuLou’s restaurant in Reno’s, um, happening, SoDo district. That means Virginia south of California and north of Plumb and there’s actually some decent food over there.
The buffet is an interesting thing: there’s a line at the door, it’s definitely sought after, but the staff and management, while competent, are not exactly going the extra mile. For example, my party wanted a booth and I asked twice if there was a booth we could sit in, and they denied us at the end even though there were booths nearby. Now in many areas of life, I go ahead and go for it, and fight for that thing I want but in this case the booth wasn’t really that important, but the seating girl’s somewhat petulant attitude did not do much to get the dinner off to a good start.
The buffet is pretty cool. As has been noted a million other places, there are not sterno pans here, but rather ceramic plates under heat lamps. This did look way better than a lot of other buffet presentations. Sadly, for some things, having them and having them there, means they should be good, and that’s not the case for every item. If I could advise a buffet operator: If it doesn’t taste good, ditch it.
Such was the case with some seafood at this buffet. I tried mahi-mahi and I tried mussels, and they both fell flat. The mahi was chewy and hard to get apart and fishy tasting and the mussels were dry and fishy tasting. Part of understanding a set of dishes and their presentation is understanding how they will stand up to the test of time, especially for a buffet chef, and I believe they could really improve this area.
One thing all reviews had led me to was the brisket, something I will visit an establishment just to try. The brisket is one area where this buffet shines. I’ve had the brisket sandwich from BBQ House on Wells, which although a nice experience and not a half bad sandwich, can’t compare with this brisket. This brisket has been cooking so long and was so well rubbed that it tastes exquisite and is not allowed to sit there long.
This buffet gets right a lot of things but on the Sunday I was there, it got wrong a lot of things. The Caesar salad bar was not working in near the right volume or really even order (the salad wasn’t terrible, but I kind of had to steel myself for it). There was some shrimpy soup that looked just like Hot and Sour, which I don’t feel comfortable judging, since I’m not Asian and you never know, that could have been good to someone.
Mashed potatoes and gravy were working flawlessly and so were various vegetables, also the desserts were fantastic.
I had some pear flavored ice cream (not gelato, but ice cream) and a little chocolate lovely thingie that had an oreo cookie as part of it that was tiny and chewy, it was pretty freakin good. Mom had bread pudding which she remembered as damn fine from before, and turns out, it is still damn fine.
The service aside from the seating girl was buffet good, and I apologize to the nice drink waiter who kept my ice tea full even though we only had like $2.25 to leave behind. THAT and the buffet was on discount, so we got in for 14 bucks each. That’s how it went.
Brisket, Prime Rib; Check. Other stuff? Hit and miss. (Mom had a few decent dishes that I can’t remember) Dessert? Of course, it’s awesome. So the Eldo buffet, is worth it at 14 bucks and quite possibly not worth it at what I understand is full price, 20 bucks. But with a little work, it could be an eater’s paradise.
Now, about my earlier Tivoli Gardens comments…